Unvote: Aldurin

This is just so we don't have any surprise lynchings. If the deadline comes up and we don't have a better lead I'll put my vote right back on.

Looked more to me like he was being facetious, and he even stated so (which I'm inclined to believe so early in the game). It's day one, so there's hardly any real pressure and I think we can trust Earl to be smarter than that after having played a few games of Mafia.

Are you sure you're not trying to start an early bandwagon after a couple people have voted (and now unvoted)?

I suddenly realize that I just tied my credibility to earl.

Why can't I keep my big mouth shut.

In all seriousness, though, I am glad that people are holdin' off. Admittedly when I made my post, I hadn't really considered Nik's argument that killing earl could deliver some working knowlege of the game's setup, which would be pretty neat. Neither had I considered his "fuck you guys" as anything other than a joke, because that's kinda the way he rolllls. I think.

I mean, I still think we have better leads. Like IHM-"let's blanket-lynch anyone who makes a particular roleclaim, even when there's a good chance we'll waste at least one lynch that way because hey they might be scum"-N. I mean, aside from the dude's overly long middle name, it just seems weird that he'd propose to lynch earl on such minimal evidence. It is day 1, but earl's claim was more of towntell than a scumtell in any case. He's a strong player, and I guess I'm sorta still giving him the benefit of the doubt?

But the fact that he's a usually strong player makes that particular screwup all the weirder. It doesn't make sense.

What would make sense would be a scum-aligned IHMN trying to use his reputation for getting stuff right to push an early lynch on earl.

So, because my flight leaves at 9 AM tomorrow, and I'm probably not gonna get online again for 24 hours, I'm gonna VOTE: IHMN

I am not at all sure about this, but, for now, it's the best lead I can think of.

Sorry about my own low post count in this game. Several things have come up in my life but I'm doing what I can to read over the posts and try to get some information from it. I'm also lacking in the in-depth experience in other games that alot of people here seem to have, so I'll have to make most of my conclusions based only what I've seen in this game.

I'm a little suspicious of Aldurin, mainly because of how rare the person he roleclaimed is, as I thought when I was signing up that we would have mainly well-known figures so no one had to go digging to find out who they were. But that isn't enough to lynch someone in my eyes.

UNVOTE: Whoever since that was the pick a name and roll with it vote. I'll wait and see if there comes up better evidence to vote for a lynch.

This is how I play the game Day 1. I have stated this time and time again. I have few opinions to offer as just about every move so far has equal probability of coming from either:

1) A townie playing the game right.
2) A mafiate playing the game right.

-OR-

1) A townie playing the game wrong.
2) A mafiate playing the game wrong.

As such, I have nothing to base any opinions off of so I will keep my non-opinions to myself thankyouverymuch.

Publically voicing opinions: Suspicious
Keeping opinions to yourself: Suspicious

Not Playing Mafia: Super Suspicious

Guys I think we should lynch Kerensky

I'm going to be honest guys. I have a sinus infection that is been messing with me the past couple days, making it really hard for me to even think straight or concentrate long enough to focus on this game.

I am leaning towards believing Aldurin for now, but not entirely convinced. Hey watch this, I'm going to be hypocritical. From how I have seen Aldurin play, he has always been the kind of person that freaks out, or always seem heavily into whatever he is going on about. He must feel strongely, ABOUT EVERYTHING. So whether his little freakout is a tell of Aldurin being Aldurin is hard to say.

and fuck it I'll look at the rest of the thread later.

I kinda forgot this was running, so uh yeah sorry for the inactivity.

Looks like conversation is dying down....

Very well then. Deadline in 48 hours.

Sorry you're not feeling well. I have been throwing up all morning myself :/

Worst case I think Aldurin is just trying to make the game interesting. Identifying Batman is going to be pretty hard because it's like 'OK how much is the theme of this Mafia game affecting how people are playing?'