It's been proven with Science that Aldurin's ideas are always bad and should be disregarded. No-Lynch is stupid. I suspect one Mafia, possibly two are alive.
So I'm going to

Vote: rpgdemon
And:
FoS: IHateMakingNames


As these are the only leads I personally see, and a lack of information in general. Gregness already got FoS'd by me earlier. One or the other just might be Scum.
By the way, repeating ideas I'd already stated the previous day, guys? *sigh*

We are sitting at 4 votes to lynch Rpgdemon, given the information ravashak has given us I believe RO was saved from the mafia during the night. With this information I believe either Gregness or Ihatemakingnames is mafia. If the game doesn't end with rpgdemons death we should move onto tackling either of those two. RO can try and night investigate again.


Fos:Gregness
Fos:Ihatemakingnames

I have to agree with RO

Do we think Mafia has power roles this game? So far, to me it seems they don't, even the Don was easily recognisable when investigated by the PO.

By extension, unless someone else is going to claim role-blocking, Gregness is town. He role blocked me (well, my predecessor, but let's ignore those irrelevant details), and as Verifiedz showed in post 1263, he got roleblocked. This is evidence of Gregness being what he says he is, a roleblocker, and me and Verifiedz being together as the CMCs, which should clear all 3 of us (and for me personally, RO investigated me).


4. Karesh, known by Sifright => probably town
7. Sifright, investigated by RO => town
9. Verifiedz, guaranteed by Ravashak as CMC => highly likely town
10. Earl, confirmed by killing the bodyguard xP => town
12. Gregness, roleblocking confirmed => town
13. rpgdemon, SK by admission
14. Ravashak, investigated by RO => town
18. Revolving Ocelot, investigations turn out right => town unless awesome puppetmaster
21. IHateMakingNames => Speaking in pictures => expected town

While I think that at this point everyone's town except rpgdemon, I can't rule out the possibility that someone isn't. If that's the case, voting a no lynch today COULD result in two night kills, followed by the SK lynch, and another night kill, cutting the group down to 5 with at least one mafia member. After some thinking, I feel this possibility is just too dangerous to allow. Therefor, I change my previous stance regarding today's lynch.

Vote: rpgdemon

Vote count

Rpgdemon: 5
Karesh
Ihatemakingnames
Sifright
Revolving Ocelot
Ravashak

No lynch: 1
Aldurin


The crowd ushers rpgdemon, Cockatrice, self-aligned onto the stage where Celestia waited.

"Ah, you must be the one who has been turning my precious little ponies to stone. This sort of behavior is inexcusable!" Celestia cried.

The cockatrice, meanwhile, began cowering.

"For your crimes, I sentence you to the harshest punishment imaginable!" Celestia's horn began to glow.

The cockatrice responded by cowering harder.

The glow Celestia's horn began to brighten. And then it continued to brighten. And then it brightened some more. The glow quickly became too bright to look at directly, much like the sun it was connected to.

"FWEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE~!"

The 3 party poppers that had materialized around the cockatrice exploded.

"Gotcha!" Celestia exclaimed. She turned to face the crowd of ponies who were, at this point, dumbfounded.

"My Little Ponies, congratulations!" Celestia announced. Her horn flashed briefly and every pony who had been removed from the town by one way or the other suddenly appeared in the town square. "You have successfully vanquished the Nightmare, her accomplices, and even the additional threats to yourselves through the power of friendship! Well done!"

With that, she left the remarkably confused townsponies to their own devices.

-----------

Dear Princess Celestia,

Today, I learned that no matter how bleak it may seem, you might get really lucky and off an entire group of cultists on the first night of a mafia game and 3/5 of the mafia in a single day/night cycle. Also, in the end, friendship can get fucked.

Your student,
Twilight Sparkle

Town Win!

sorry I suck as a GM guys

Naw, it was good. Do we get an after action report like in snakes game? I totally want to hear how terrible i was and how much i deserved to get lynched :p

I can do that after I give this presentation of death for my Music History class in 2 hours.

Man, over in the cult we had most of the mafia and some of the power roles pegged (not 100% but we turned out to be pretty right) day 1 but then we all died night 1. I was grabbing Hawk night 1 then Nikose would have been nigth 2 giving us the Vig kill and the mafia by day 2.
Fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk.

Did we ever work out what Snake was? Cause he was tots mental.

Also you dudes were a mental town.

Wait, so did I hit 2 scum then? Because if I did then I can consider myself a successful vig. Also, please never give me vig powers again. Vig is hard man, I was so worried I was gona fuck up.

2 questions though;

SMB, why did you try and convert me first? There were far better targets than me.

Likewise to mafia, did I do something obvious to get killed on night 3? Cos SMB and Snake I can understand, seeing as they're mafia vets and are pretty good at the game, but I'm not nearly that high a priority, unless you knew something.

Still, least I got to be RD. That was all that matters really.:)

Because I had a hunch you had a power role. It was based on your posting patterns day 1, i can't remember exactly what trigged me but I was sure you had to go night 1.
I didn't think you were mafia (I think I had Nikose, Ryanderman, Greed on my speculated mafia list) but there was something funny so I took a shot.
It was either you or snake. Who knows what snake was up to.
And it would have worked too if not for you meddling ponies.

You were a low activity poster, pretty much guarantees you to be power role or mafia. New mafia players tend to try the incognito approach when mafia or power rollin and mafia players all know who each other are.


Edit: also totally vindicated I said nikose was mafia from like day 2.

Double edit: Hawk you hit cult on night 1 and mafia on night 3 so thats pretty sweet.