Yes that seems to be the implication. The criminals of Arkham are town, and Batman and co. are the informed minority (see: mafia).

All we know from that is that Karesh is not Mr. Freeze. Mr. Freeze is a jailer role, in that he removes people from play for a day, after which they are able to play.

Look at Kerensky's role in Fuck You Mafia (kinda) for NPF-based reference.

Ok, so we have a jailer, but it doesn't really do much good, as it doesn't reveal anything about the person jailed. Duno why Karesh was targetted either, could be the jailer just wanted to let it be known that this power existed and was town friendly, or see just how the power worked, in which case fair enough. Basically it's like a weaker version of the fingerbang from Fuck You mafia.

Probably only be useful once we have some clear suspicions to go on to keep scum out of the game for a while whilst we deal with other threats.

Yellow text can either mean that the character is town-aligned or that the GM doesn't wish to give away alignments. I typically use cyan for that when I GM (to avoid this discussion entirely) but I haven't seen too many other players pick up that habit so I dunno.

Given the multitude of people immediately claiming that they too are Batman villains and town-aligned, then the former is likely.

Please tell me this isn't a serious claim. Because I am actually the miller, Mr. Thomas Elliot McWTF. Apparently I'm a miller because of some shit about looking the same as Bruce Wayne.

Watch as I actually play the Miller role properly in a way that doesn't mess up the town.

Vote: Hawk

I'm assuming his claim is serious until he clarifies either joke post or actually trying to argue that he's the miller.

I was just foolin' 'round we don't know jack shit.

Vote: Aldurin

Because I need to throw a vote somewhere and Hawk was pretty clearly joking.

Either that, or ONE of you two IS Batman, and is trying to hide behind the roll of Thomas Elliot, Childhood Friend!

Seems like a smart roleclaim for disguising the 'don', as it were.
FOS: Hawk on that logic; and if that fails-

Possible FOS: Aldurin, not even bolding it yet though.

I'm more then willing to be suspicious of them both, because Hawk is WAY too serious [very BATMAN like, if you will~] and Aldurin is Aldurin and costs the town nothing if he vanishes mysteriously.

Actually, shame on Freeze for not Jailing Aldurin. >:C

Aldurin, it was a joke, in response to ICs blatant "Look her's me being blatantly scummy" post. Clearly it went over your head.

Please note how I actually only started being genuinely serious after the part where I SAID I was going to be serious. Everything before that was clearly joke posting and if you can't see that then you're stupid.