The Warring States of NPF

The Warring States of NPF (http://www.nuklearforums.com/index.php)
-   Dead threads (http://www.nuklearforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=91)
-   -   #681: "That's how we like it." (http://www.nuklearforums.com/showthread.php?t=13762)

Piedmon Sama 04-05-2006 04:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Swiftbow
I've mentioned this before, but I really dislike the whole "elves start at 110" thing. You mentioned homebrew rules... in all of mine, elves mature at about 20 (same as humans) and just live longer (ie, longer adult time). Some have argued that living longer must equal longer childhood time, but this is clearly not the case. See parrots and those huge tortoises. Childhood time is very short, but they live as long or longer than many humans.

I think the goofiest thing about elves starting at 110 is the idea that they'd be in diapers for what, 10 years? I think their parents would absolutely lose it at that point. I mean, elves apparently love nothing more than living in silent contemplation... and here the danged baby is bawling every few hours.

That way is fine, too. Personally I get sick of supposedly centurion Elves who act like temperamental and impatient humans all the time, and I ought to know as my current regular D&D campaign encorporates no less than three of the bastards. (Well, two now. One recently became ground pizza after failing a jump check. Serves her right for thinking the name "Death Chasm" was just for tourists.)

Honestly, when you take into account that an Elf is supposed to have seen no less than a century of life on this earth, making him older than all but the most venerable humans, you HAVE to take into account the kind of perspective that brings if you want to RP your Elf at all believably. I know expounding cliches is generally bad form for roleplaying, but in this case it isn't just because "Elves are that way." It's because they're 110 years old, and it would take some serious learning disability if they didn't gain some kind of temperance from that. So Elves really should, as a rule, be patient, mature, generally calm and hard to shock. After all, they've been around for a century.

They should NOT punch out other party members for making a lewd comment, or become wandering prostitutes, or be generally credulous and gullible cottonheads. I have to DM Elves who act like the cast of Dawson's Creek and it makes me want to cry.

BetaRuler 04-05-2006 05:13 AM

Wooo! Elves civilisation got owned :p

But somehow youknow, I woulda liked to have seen one of the best points there being made by fighter, he usually makes some of the best ones when it comes to stuff like that I think.

JONJONAUG 04-05-2006 05:17 AM

If anyone wants a good point on this, remember the very, very long-lived people from Golden Sun.

Lived so long, but children had the same time spent as a child as any other normal human. They said that "children were precious" to them because of it. Maybe elves adore children like that too.

...no, not in the Jackson way, the NORMAL way.

Galumphing 04-05-2006 08:49 AM

I agree to the elf-comments. In the campains i GM (not D&D, but fantasy still) I create the characters myself, and i always have a hard time with the elfs, coz' they are two to three times as old as anyone else, and equally experienced! Grumble, mumble... Hate it.

Oh, and going back on-topic, this comic was just so good. Really.

Art of Hilt 04-05-2006 10:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jared Todd
Nice try.



Utterly, cunning, comprived, truthful, embarrassing. "Eh", or "hmm", or even "huh" aren't words. and what's up with capitalizing non-names/places in the middle of sentence? Thank you very much. *bows*

Now... eugh. To work out my huge problem with wording things.




Fighter's foot doesn't look like it would have been that long, that was the point. I barely even worked on those sprites. and Red Mage's foot... you can see it under the cape a bit; his foot 'looked too long' as well, I think... thought... I don't know anymore.




Ooh, I almost went out on an all-defense before I noticed your "if" at the start of that sentence.
Umm.. no, I'm not blaming you for anything, and not blamming you for anything on top of that. I'm saying that your work on all the sprites look like they would be in FF1, but not FF3. The work I do, and the work I did on those sprites are much more appealing to they eye, even if they aren't correct. You have to admit that having Fighter's leg twisted back longer than his body looks odd, especially if a bit of the leg should be invisible under the chocobo's ear/horn/thing. But if you notice, the taller sprites all have legs that are hugely bigger than their bodies.
I love your work, SWB, I would never, ever try to peg you down for the spriting you've done. I've just noticed that the sprites aren't... new-looking and perfect for the eye like the assorted colors and "square line" work I do. Like, White Mage's hair underneath her cloak looks kind of off and oddly-shaped. But I still have yet to be able to do poses like you've made.

and on that note, all I have to say is I wish I had something else to say. Besides making fun to peg myself down in everyone elses' eye, and defend myself, throwing things offtopic once again. Though, I don't believe that I should've sent this in PM; I think that it should be able to be viewed to set other people- that haven't looked at your work so closely and realised it's as good as it is- straight. Because it is very much better than first glance. I've just had to work with your sprites, and FF1-3 sprites a lot more than most people.

SWB, your work is great, I'm so sorry...
T T

I'm sorry, you were just asking for it. >_> Although I noticed that you never capitalise "And", even if it's at the beginning of the sentence. Why? <_<

Now, getting back on topic.

It was so very awesome- and I mean awesome, as in "AWESOME D00DZERZ INCORREKT SPILLING N CAPSLOX CRUUSE CONTRL FER TEH KEWL" awesome- seeing Thief put in such a situation.

Seriously. It was.

Because, I have this seething hate of all things "Elf". From what I understand, they are almost exactly like human beings, but just better at everything. Including having better looks, which- from my knowledge- isn't something a whole goddamned race can have in their genes.

Novasol 04-05-2006 11:02 AM

Of course Elven technology isn't on par with the humans'. How could it be when the humans have King Steve? He invented inventing.

Jared Todd 04-05-2006 11:24 AM

"blam" is a term used on Newgrounds and a bit of quirky English people use it too. and I've heard it used in real life.. it means insult, or kick down a step. and I believe, according to english class for 5 years, you shouldn't start sentences with "and" in the first place, like "of" or "again" or "because" and stuff..

and I have no idea where you get "they eye" from. You must've put an extra "y" there while changing the font red. v.v'''''


On topic.. > >
Some elves are pure awesome. The elves in this world..? No. God no. I dislike the elves in this world a lot. Which... are basically the majority of how people write elves. Which is bad. The dwarves..? I have to say, I love the dwarves here. They're so great. That's why my favourite character inside the comic is Berserker.

and was there anywhere in the comic that said Thief was in teenager-dom longer than RM/Fighter/BM? I thought Thief said it in one of the comics when they were talking about BM being a teenager. or was that just in one of the threads on the forum at the time..? I'm confused as hell, because my mind's telling me that Thief's mentioned he's had a longer childhood than the rest of them, but my gut's telling me he didn't!! T T

Art of Hilt 04-05-2006 01:55 PM

Quote:

"blam" is a term used on Newgrounds and a bit of quirky English people use it too. and I've heard it used in real life.. it means insult, or kick down a step. and I believe, according to english class for 5 years, you shouldn't start sentences with "and" in the first place, like "of" or "again" or "because" and stuff..

and I have no idea where you get "they eye" from. You must've put an extra "y" there while changing the font red. v.v'''''
"Blamming" = my bad.
"They eye" = I don't remember touching that "Y" key. >_> Maybe it's a ghost "Y". "YGCA". Where ghosts go to excersize and stuff. <_<
".and" = you should've used a comma, then. And you are allowed to start sentences with "And", "Because", and so on. So says hundreds of books, and English class for a very, very long time.

Back on topic-

There was this one comic that showed a picture of a baby saying, "I'm a forty year old virgin. Creepy, huh?" on here somewhere, but I'm too lazy to look. I'm pretty sure it's just a funny thing to add, but maybe these Elves take a very long time to age from childhood? Maybe? Please? Then it can be even easier to poke fun at them. I want to poke fun at them, goshdarnit!

Fifthfiend 04-05-2006 02:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Piedmon Sama
That way is fine, too. Personally I get sick of supposedly centurion Elves who act like temperamental and impatient humans all the time, and I ought to know as my current regular D&D campaign encorporates no less than three of the bastards. (Well, two now. One recently became ground pizza after failing a jump check. Serves her right for thinking the name "Death Chasm" was just for tourists.)

Honestly, when you take into account that an Elf is supposed to have seen no less than a century of life on this earth, making him older than all but the most venerable humans, you HAVE to take into account the kind of perspective that brings if you want to RP your Elf at all believably. I know expounding cliches is generally bad form for roleplaying, but in this case it isn't just because "Elves are that way." It's because they're 110 years old, and it would take some serious learning disability if they didn't gain some kind of temperance from that. So Elves really should, as a rule, be patient, mature, generally calm and hard to shock. After all, they've been around for a century.

They should NOT punch out other party members for making a lewd comment, or become wandering prostitutes, or be generally credulous and gullible cottonheads. I have to DM Elves who act like the cast of Dawson's Creek and it makes me want to cry.

It's not like there aren't plenty of venerable humans who aren't just outright ornery old assholes. Shit, I know old people who would cock-punch you for making a dirty joke and tell you to shut the fuck up and then turn right around and repeat the same joke to their shitty-old-man buddies and laugh their heads off. And believe you me, if my Grandma had the body of your average D&D elf, she'd be fucking everything on two legs and and probably a few on four. I'm not saying old people don't have perspective, I'm just saying that perspective tends to be 'fuck everybody else, I'm old and I don't give a shit.' So I don't necessarily see why Elves should have to be any different.

Lucis 04-05-2006 02:42 PM

I probably shouldn't get involved, but I'd like to make a polite request here... could all those involved please cease the grammar nitpicking? I'd sincerely appreciate it.

Back on topic...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Art of Hilt
I have this seething hate of all things "Elf". From what I understand, they are almost exactly like human beings, but just better at everything. Including having better looks, which- from my knowledge- isn't something a whole goddamned race can have in their genes.

It could be possible, if they've been practicing eugenics (selective breeding between sentients) all this time. It would also explain so much else about the elves, like their slow technological advancement, for instance. Humans are adaptable because they're fairly opportunistic when it comes to breeding; they'll take what they can get. As a result, humans may be "uglier" (rather subjective - I find most elves unpleasantly sharp-featured, personally) on the whole, but they do not restrict potentially useful genes just because they happened to be possessed by an ugly individual. The only time I can recall humans widely practicing eugenics was in Nazi Germany (it was one of the Nazi's reasonings behind the Holocaust, that Jews were an inferior race and needed to be eliminated for the betterment of humanity), and look what happened to them.

As for elves being "better at everything," that's just elven propaganda; it's what they believe, and what they want everyone else to believe. As Red Mage and Black Mage proved in the last comic, elves have their issues just like everyone else. The difference comes in that they're more prone to covering it up with polite euphemisms and hiding it from everyone else. It's a testament to their propaganda skills that they've managed to maintain their mythos of being "superior" for so long. After all, in several Tolkienistic worlds, elves control only a very small amount of territory, and frequently are being herded into ever-smaller areas by encroaching humans and goblinoids. Considering that they once "controlled the world," in these worlds, one must wonder WTF happened. Clearly, elves aren't as superior as they want everyone to believe if mere humans and goblinoids can oust most of their empire in the span of a few thousand years.

On the whole, however, I can understand your distaste for all things elven. Their language is needlessly complex and flowery, they're needlessly complex and flowery, they bleed and break easy when subjected to physical torment, they're narcissistic, haughty, arrogant, racist and xenophobic, and aside from their magic and magic items (which they do not trade to other races often) they produce no worthwhile goods or services. At least dwarves are excellent smiths and miners, in a lot of Tolkienistic worlds, trade the fruits of their labor with nearby human communities for food, cloth, and leather.

Pfft, elves. They're so wrapped up in their "long-term view of the world" that they're going to going to get pounded in the here-and-now unless they pull their heads out of their butts and stop reminiscing/future gazing long enough to do something about it. This is why I respect Thief a bit more than most elves - unlike the rest of his pointy-eared, tree-huggin' kind, he actually goes out and does stuff rather than sit around posturing and posing and looking down his nose at other races while they figure out which pose they want him in before he takes an axe to the neck. As greed pointed out awhile ago, the elves and dwarves are in a more-or-less perpetual state of war over the Earth Orb, and the Light(bulb) Warriors managed to do more damage to the dwarves in the course of a few comics than the entire elven race has done. Just goes to show you what two humans, one black mage, and an elf-who-actually-makes-himself-useful can do, compared to an entire race of narcissistic screw-your-neighbor hippies.

You know, that makes me wonder. We've never seen Thief's mother, the Queen of Elfland, have we? Could Thief possibly be half-elven? He does seem to be awfully robust, practical, and open-minded compared to your average elf.

Apologies for the rather longwinded post/rant


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:51 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.