The Warring States of NPF

The Warring States of NPF (http://www.nuklearforums.com/index.php)
-   Playing Games (http://www.nuklearforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Oh shit, a Steam Autumn Sale, NOT ENOUGH MONEY (http://www.nuklearforums.com/showthread.php?t=42333)

Solid Snake 11-26-2012 03:25 PM

In this topic: historical revisionists
 
I wasn't the slightest bit snarky when I was made the original post you all responded to, which merely elucidated that Crusader Kings II (a game I like, by the way, and one I'm usually more eager to defend) is saddled with a fair share of issues related to social justice concerns that might caution against its purchase.

Y'all then proceeded to react with:

Quote:

Are there honestly people out there that think a game striving for social and political realism situated in the 11th century should not portray the biases of that time and instead be unrealistically progressive?
Quote:

I'm pretty sure that by that definition Civilization is also "socially unjust"
...And even after you expressed this initial round of, yes, holier-than-thou know-it-all bona fide snarkiness in response to my otherwise innocuous attempt to inform, I graciously proceeded to try to explain the specific substantive issues in a post or two without delving into name-calling.

Instead, y'all proceeded to attempt to prove me wrong and/or lecture me, with a continued flippant tone:

Quote:

You're doin that logic thing again, Arcanum. Stop that silliness right now!
Quote:

You sure you did your homework on that one?
Yes, Bells, that last comment of yours I quoted was snarky and sarcastic and self-indulgent and uses wording that is at best completely unnecessary and at worst utterly dismissive.

Yes, I'm sure I "did my homework" on that one.
And yes, by the time we had gotten that far -- by the time I had already elucidated in three separate posts my line of reasoning -- I finally gave in to temptation and decided to inject some snark because you were already tossing out your zingers at me for daring to suggest that a game I actually LIKE has genuine issues.

And no, I shouldn't have to justify every attempt I make to preface recommendations for videogames with a social-justice related disclaimer.
This is the kind of attitude and behavior that makes talking about issues like sexism and homophobia utterly impossible here at NPF.

Marc v4.0 11-26-2012 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bells (Post 1217066)
Snake reacts like this



When someone simply asks confirmation on data that he said goes one way, while the (albeit little) research i did, showed something else... so i asked.

But it is ok to react like that... cause he is morally upright, you see?

You didn't "simply ask" Bells, you directly challenged in a manner that tried to cast doubt or suspicion on the veracity of his knowledge.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bells (Post 1217058)
what am i missing here if the Crusader Kings II wiki states that the Homosexual Trait only reduces fertility by 15% and nothing else ?

That is simply asking.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bells (Post 1217058)
You sure you did your homework on that one?

That is being condescendingly snide and then turning around and acting the morally better better person because you 'did nothing wrong'.

We can all read here, we didn't miss it.

E:FB

Solid Snake 11-26-2012 03:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arcanum (Post 1217064)
Is that directed at me? While my original post was based in a lack of understanding of how deep these mechanics ran, it doesn't merit a snide remark like this. Seriously, what the fuck?

For clarification's sake: No.
That was directed at Skweeb.
I did lose my cool there. I felt Skweeb's comment crossed a line.
The previous post I wrote -- one where I didn't lose my cool -- was one that directly quoted and responded to you. I'm not even sure if you commented after that (I don't think you did, at least not until now.)

Grandmaster_Skweeb 11-26-2012 04:09 PM

Look, you're givin me too much credit for tryin to stir up shit. I agree that the mechanics of some aspects of the game are silly and illogical, and frankly downright stupid in execution. Trying to make sense why they made it so is the illogical part i was alluding to.

If i really wanted to stir up shit i'd say something like "all we need now is someone to bring up entitlement so i can claim social justice bingo!"

So, if what i said is soooo offensive, then i apologize on that one.

Solid Snake 11-26-2012 04:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Grandmaster_Skweeb (Post 1217075)
Look, you're givin me too much credit for tryin to stir up shit. I agree that the mechanics of some aspects of the game are silly and illogical, and frankly downright stupid in execution. Trying to make sense why they made it so is the illogical part i was alluding to.

I am about 99.9% certain that Paradox's team had conversations about every trait they put in the game, how those traits would correlate and intertwine, and how best to balance their gameplay while retaining a semblance of historical authenticity. So no, I don't buy that their usage of homosexuality as a negative trait was "silly and illogical." I think if you'd ask a Paradox designer they'd come up with a litany of historical reasons -- mostly regarding past persecution of homosexuals -- to justify its inclusion.
They'd be wrong, but there are reasons why they were wrong in their approach that can be perceived and understood.

Any 'illogical stupidity' from Paradox in their game doesn't immunize the product from criticism, for that matter.

I don't buy your explanation that you weren't trying to start controversy, by the way. Even your half-assed attempt at an 'apology' right there is offensive.

Grandmaster_Skweeb 11-26-2012 04:29 PM

Christ this shit's gettin ridiculous, i'm out. Take the half-assed attempt or not, I dont particularly care either way 'cause that's all that is going to be given.

POS Industries 11-26-2012 05:13 PM

Please return to the topic of outrageous holiday deals on video games.

If you want to continue discussing the problematic nature of Crusader Kings II: Bigotry Boogaloo, you may feel free to make a thread for that if you are able to remain respectful and reasonable in the process.

Ramary 11-26-2012 05:20 PM

Will do sir.


Anyone intrested in Castle Crashers? I remember kinda liking it on the xbox and might get a 4 pack to keep making people feel indebted to me.

Kim 11-26-2012 05:21 PM

Comrades! I hear of a place beyond the Great Valve Wall! A land where deals are in abundance, not just one day or two but all year round! Let us raise our banners! Let us shout our battle cry! Tonight the wall falls! Tonight... Tonight we know freedom.

BB 11-26-2012 05:22 PM

Today is the last sale day (although, possibly, there's one more round of flash sales to come), so it's time to hoover up all the things you haven't bought yet in case they went on a daily deal.

Also, Bastion's on flash sale right now. You won't spend a better $4.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:09 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.