Close one, but I'm going Tombstone.

Gangs of New York or Matchstick Men?

Unforunately only saw MM, so saying that.

Chicago or Hairspray

Reminding people to view my first post in this thread as I have had to place 3 people on probation and I'm not kidding around about it.

Hmm...numerous sexy ladies in sexy clothing or some fat chick who wants to be a dancer...Chicago.

Battle of the Horrible Trilogy Endings

Back to the Future III or Matrix Revolutions.

This is a hard one, but...Back To The Future III.

Platoon or Apocalypse Now?

APOCOLYPSE NOW!!

Excalibur or Highlander?

Highlander, defintely.

Dr. No or Live and Let Die?

Dr. No

Dragonheart or The Neverending Story?

Dragonheart

SUPAR COMEDIAN DVD BATTLE:

Eddie Izzard's "Dressed to Kill" or Eddie Izzard's "Circle" ?

Dressed to Kill by a little. Though honestly I preferred glorious to both of those!

glitter or gigli? (ouch!)