socksmakepeoplesexy.net - Polly, the person who runs the site, is just a fantastically nice person, she's fair about the stuff she uploads from other people, and the reviews I've seen from her are pretty great. I don't always agree with them, but that's not what reviewing is about.
Freelance Astronauts - These guys are THE best LP guys I've seen, and they've got a pretty huge archive.
In case you need any reason to check their stuff out...
Gamepad Dojo - Weekly reviews from Mirai and myself, and Azisien does some stuff for us, too. We also have a review by Batgirl up, and will most likely have something from another NPFer up in the near future. We also have a forums.