Quote:
Originally Posted by Geminex
Crit: Oh god I am weary of this.
Now, Menarker. I am not going to reply to your post. Do you know why? Because you make no new points. Each and every one of the points you make I have already addressed (except, admittedly, for the one regarding Renny's pokeshift, but that's peanuts). I want you to go back and read those responses I wrote. Do you think you can do that? You don't seem to have done it so far, but give it a great big try and maybe we'll actually be able to, y'know, progress in this discussion instead of spending 2000 words regurgitating the same points over and over again.
|
Gem, we're never going to proceed any further with your attitude.
I even gave you numbered reasons that you never addressed ONCE even when I listed them before.
Your main insistance has been that speed has been neglected and that it should be the prime focus of the stat.
What you failed to answer repeatably, was WHY your suggestions is not over-powering broken for the system (or mine for that matter since I maintain even my suggestions probably need tuning down). Why is 25%-50% crit acceptable with the ease that is presented? Is doubling the attack power of everyone with a speed boost acceptable? And that's among other valid questions which you shrugged off as belaboring the point!
You have been so focused on trying to win the battle on Speed that you forget the battle has not been on speed but Crit in the first place. You also keep saying that changes to the system need to be constantly evaluated for balance and explosive differences. This is one of them and you're taking the lazy way out of the conversation and making me seem like the useless one.
Would be nice if you could actually, y'know put the same effort into answering the questions as I do coming up with them and typing them and adding them up in charts instead of accusing me of spewing the same stuff over and over. I mean really, if you're supposed to be dealing with balance in AB's behalf, you can't be going half-ass on it. You're SUPPOSED to be answering the questions, so I have a basis of knowing why or why not certain points were brought up.
You say I fail to make new points? You failed to make any worthwhile contribution to the conversation aside from a proposed system that you can't even coherently explain the reasons why it would work in a balanced fashion.
Quote:
|
Prepare to find yourself in a world where Renny is dead, Impact is demoted to comic relief and every single girl is constantly fucking Pierce at the same time.
|
That's the only way they might consider doing it. Seriously, your imagination about getting all the girls is not going to happen. Especially with all the warnings that AB made about Pierce going into an early unmarked grave if you tried. :3
Drac, on a side note, do you have any thoughts on the crit conversation? It would seem rather relevant to you since your Kingdra happens to be one of the pokemons that would benefit heavily from crit (since it has the sniper ability that triples instead of doubles damage when it scores a crit) and Kingdra being... you know, not that fast.
That and your Blaziken can learn Blaze Kick which is a improved crit move. And most pokemons can learn Stone Edge. And Spacial Rend which belongs to Palkia is an improved crit.