My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

Professor Smarmiarty · 09-24-2011, 11:43 AM

I don't know, I feel a bit like Snake's shut us down a bit- normallly (read: every mafia game on here except hthe last one) we through out some random votes then somebody in response says something totally suspect and we lynch them and all their buddies. Works pretty well then.
I don't know how we're supposed to get info now that Snake has called out the random voters, all the scum can just hide behind the "I didn't want to be a random voter" now.
If it was anybody else I would think it was a bit scummy but to be honest it fits with Snakes posting so Imma chalk it up to snake being snake..

So in lieu of that we could try and figure out what kind of roles we think are floating around though this would arm the scum with fake role claims potentially so I don't think we should do that.

So I'm asking Snake- without the churning activity causing byrandom voting how do you suggest we proceed day 1?
The only thing I can come up with is rounding out the inactives- Sif posted that it could help the Scum I don't agree. The scum k now who each other are, they don't want information to be spread around the town- the more the town talks the more likely scum will be given away/incriminated. The problem last game was half the town not really playing- so there was little discussion and the scum had strong control of the vote.
But I mean this is not my favoured plan but I don't have any other one right now.
More posting//opinions from other players wouldbeuseful.

09-24-2011, 11:43 AM	#11
Professor Smarmiarty Sent to the cornfield Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: K-space Posts: 9,758	I don't know, I feel a bit like Snake's shut us down a bit- normallly (read: every mafia game on here except hthe last one) we through out some random votes then somebody in response says something totally suspect and we lynch them and all their buddies. Works pretty well then. I don't know how we're supposed to get info now that Snake has called out the random voters, all the scum can just hide behind the "I didn't want to be a random voter" now. If it was anybody else I would think it was a bit scummy but to be honest it fits with Snakes posting so Imma chalk it up to snake being snake.. So in lieu of that we could try and figure out what kind of roles we think are floating around though this would arm the scum with fake role claims potentially so I don't think we should do that. So I'm asking Snake- without the churning activity causing byrandom voting how do you suggest we proceed day 1? The only thing I can come up with is rounding out the inactives- Sif posted that it could help the Scum I don't agree. The scum k now who each other are, they don't want information to be spread around the town- the more the town talks the more likely scum will be given away/incriminated. The problem last game was half the town not really playing- so there was little discussion and the scum had strong control of the vote. But I mean this is not my favoured plan but I don't have any other one right now. More posting//opinions from other players wouldbeuseful.