My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Hawk

Al, I told you not to do that again. Why would you do that again? So far town hasn't had the chance to make a decent lynch of its own and you keep wanting to override us. What ARE you playing at??!

Still, at least we know you're powerless now, though your irrational nature and apparant poor judgement lead me to believe I should no more trust anything you say than anyone else in this game, despite your confirmed town status.

On that note however, yes, I agree greed is shifty looking. Far too much inactivity for my liking, alongside Ryanderman. Greed also turned up just a few hours after somebody else started getting suspicious of him, and judging by the way inactives have been falling out of this game he might be getting worried he's next.

I'm also still suspicious of Sifright. Twice now he's called out the PO to confirm his town status and I've had an off feeling about him since that whole confirmation thing with Karesh. He could easily have been scum trying to lure out a clear townie in Fluttershy, with the hope that Fluttershy would be a power role to kill off. This of course was immediately negated by the fact that Karesh claims Fluttershy is bulletproof, which would make the mafia think twice about attempting a kill.

And from what I'm gathering from last night, it appears both the mafia and SK tried to kill Zecora, with one overiding the other, which would seem to indicate that Fenris IS giving us fluff info about failed kills. So the mafia wouldn't bother to test Kareshs claim if they suspected he's bulletproof, because it would only confirm that he's town for the rest of us in the fluff. Besides which there's plenty of other targets to go after and they could pretty much ignore the unkillables if they wanted.

Then there's Sifs finger pointing about Fawful, which, as indicated, involves a lot of players, including some confirmed town (even "his" confirmed town Karesh was mentioned as being wary of Fawful). But as we know, Fawful was taken down by the vig, so I don't know why this finger pointing is even going on, unless he's pointing fingers at people he thinks is the vig, which is pure scum. You do NOT point fingers at the vig, ever.

All this leads me to beleive that Sif is trying to lure out power roles so the mafia can kill them, and for that reason

Vote: Sifright

Scratch that just reread his post. I'm wary of people that went after Fawful because we found out that Fawful was town (unless you're presuming pinkie pie wasn't town) and two was completely inactive killing 100% inactive people is something i've been against since the START.

Bare in mind voting people shouldn't ever be about one single issue baring a PO going THIS DUDE HERE IS SCUM. We aren't looking for a single smoking gun because you won't find that it has to be about a multitude of issues which stack up over the course of a few game days.

Unfortunately with my handling of certain key issues that puts me in the firing line as well I mean there is legitimate reason to be wary of me.

So yes I went back and looked over people that I believe could be scum to see how they handled voting with regards to Fawful it's why I pointed out RPGDEMON as wanting to kill an inactive because he voted for him which is ostensibly the most important action a person can do. I know Karesh isn't scum but that doesn't mean he can't do things that seem scummy to me.

[Sifright]

You know what i'm going to slave my votes to karesh, I know he isn't scum. Thats good enough for me.

Unvote:Rpgdemon

Vote:Greed

[Fenris]

Sifright, could you like, do me a huge favor and only post one post per coherent thought?

You're sitting at like, 90 more posts than the second place poster but that's because you're posting like 8 posts per 1 bit of content.

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Fenris

Sifright, could you like, do me a huge favor and only post one post per coherent thought?

You're sitting at like, 90 more posts than the second place poster but that's because you're posting like 8 posts per 1 bit of content.

I'll shut up now.

[Ryanderman]

I don't think he's asking you to shut up. Just, contain your thoughts to single posts in a row?

Before I change my vote to greed, as I really don't like just following the crowd without understanding the reason, could you explain why we're voting for him? We've got all this argument against rpgdemon, and we're voting for greed? Is it just his lack of posting much, and not contributing much to the discussion?

[Nikose Tyris]

UNVOTE: GREED

Because actually

VOTE: RPGDEMON

Because Sifright.

[Oron]

Got back from class and read back through a few posts. I've been stuck on the whole "Sifright vs. RPG" fiasco.

Sif's self votes almost seem like bluffs, as if he's saying, "Vote for me. I dare you." Well, the second one sounded pretty ragequit-ish, but he voted for himself and promptly said how stupid voting for him was while RO and Karesh basically said, "Stop that."

It might just seem like that to me because I've been keeping RPG's arguments in mind while reading through the last couple game-days, though. He's made some points that I thought were agreeable, but he has been pretty ardent in questioning Sifright.

It's kind of a split in between the two in my mind, so I'm going to hold off on voting for a little bit. I'm still really busy because I basically have two or three exams every week (last week was my only week without exams for the last month and a half, which is why I was more active then than I am now). I'll come check on this again later tonight.

[Oron]

Logged back in real quick for a little clarification:

It was Sifright's second self-vote that seemed most bluff-like to me, mostly because:
1) It was the second time he did it.
2) He made that vote in response to RPG pressuring him. That made me think of RPG voting himself into a lynch in the Homestuck Mafia game.

Now I'm off for real.

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Oron

Got back from class and read back through a few posts. I've been stuck on the whole "Sifright vs. RPG" fiasco.

Sif's self votes almost seem like bluffs, as if he's saying, "Vote for me. I dare you." Well, the second one sounded pretty ragequit-ish, but he voted for himself and promptly said how stupid voting for him was while RO and Karesh basically said, "Stop that."

It might just seem like that to me because I've been keeping RPG's arguments in mind while reading through the last couple game-days, though. He's made some points that I thought were agreeable, but he has been pretty ardent in questioning Sifright.

It's kind of a split in between the two in my mind, so I'm going to hold off on voting for a little bit. I'm still really busy because I basically have two or three exams every week (last week was my only week without exams for the last month and a half, which is why I was more active then than I am now). I'll come check on this again later tonight.

No the first time I sincerely believed that me dieing would be best for town. Confirming karesh was high on my priority list because i believed we had a near 100% chance of lynching a townie regardless and that me dieing would give the town Karesh to form around. I mean I didn't want to be removed from the game but I honestly believed it was for the best with town. I still to this moment can't understand Snakes thinking with not wanting me to be lynched until day 4.

The second time I legitimately was just giving up, I still don't think we can win we have no information on whats going on. Nikose has been shown to be lying and yet there was a lynch wagon forming around me. So forgive me for thinking my death was going to be inevitable and deciding that town was fucked.

See if Nikose had said "I'm the PO" I wouldn't have been out for him to be lynched but like he's coming from a "Maybe i'm a fake PO" which is sketchy as hell. The only thing that worries me is that Snake could have been a miller role which shows up as Scum to the PO. So I'm not sure what to do but again the obscure character is worrying and the fact that he isn't one of the core six from the show makes it unlikely he has a power role.

[Nikose Tyris]

Originally Posted by Sifright

See if Nikose had said "I'm the PO" I wouldn't have been out for him to be lynched but like he's coming from a "Maybe i'm a fake PO" which is sketchy as hell. The only thing that worries me is that Snake could have been a miller role which shows up as Scum to the PO. So I'm not sure what to do but again the obscure character is worrying and the fact that he isn't one of the core six from the show makes it unlikely he has a power role.

Actually, that's incredibly smart. I just assumed I was smarter then Fenris and knew I was a Fake PO.

...Well shit. that's actually horrible then, that I might be the real PO. :/

Why are you logicking this out better then me. Sif?