Mafia Time!

[Kerensky287]

Lawful, how do you know you were protected overnight?

[Kerensky287]

Further reason to FoS Gregness that I just noticed: He claimed this didn't seem like a power game, which I suspect is what led to him claiming vanilla.

However, here are the roles we know of/have seen claimed:
-Me, vig
-Lawful, 2xvoter
-Inbred, mafia roleblocker
-Nikose, miller/dickbag
-Geminex, Marshmallow Boy #3, probable mason
-RPGdemon, probable mason
-A third mason
-Greed, role selector

That's 8 players in a 14-player game with some kind of unusual role. More than 50%. That just screams power game to me, which leads me to believe that Gregness is lying about his role.

[Lawful Neutral]

I received a PM from Bard explaining that I was protected for the remainder of Night 1.
The flavor text included mentioned a bird giving me the armor, so I don't doubt him.

[Gregness]

Originally Posted by Kerensky287

Further reason to FoS Gregness that I just noticed: He claimed this didn't seem like a power game, which I suspect is what led to him claiming vanilla.

However, here are the roles we know of/have seen claimed:
-Me, vig
-Lawful, 2xvoter
-Inbred, mafia roleblocker
-Nikose, miller/dickbag
-Geminex, Marshmallow Boy #3, probable mason
-RPGdemon, probable mason
-A third mason
-Greed, role selector

That's 8 players in a 14-player game with some kind of unusual role. More than 50%. That just screams power game to me, which leads me to believe that Gregness is lying about his role.

I didn't mean to imply that this was entirely a vanilla game. I imagine the degree of powers is something just below the saturation in the MLP mafia game. And, if you take a look at that list and what I said which was:

Originally Posted by Gregness

Well, I'm not sure there are that many power roles to begin with. The last few games have been crazy, high powered affairs but this game seems much more standard so far. I wouldn't expect there to be much more than a cop a doc and a vig with some people having some one-shot things.

The important part being:

I wouldn't expect there to be much more than a cop a doc and a vig with some people having some one-shot things.

You'll note in that list you gave that basically holds. Few power roles =\= vanilla. Like, maybe this is just semantics on my part, but when I say power roles I think of repeatable or constant effects. I would honestly be very surprised if mafia had any more power roles. Maybe a strongman, but I dunno. Double-voting is kind of cute, I guess, but it's sort of 150% of a vanilla townie if that makes sense. I think trying to construe "miller" as a power role would be too much of a stretch for Mr. Fantastic. Then only thing it does is serve to make the cop (if one exists) weaker.

Mason is cool, I guess, but still kind of tame for the power level of the last few games in the forum.

The big point, to re-emphasize, is that I don't think low power =\= vanilla.

Like, I dunno, nothing I said is contradicted by facts and if wasn't already 95% sure you were legit with your townie Vig this would be some serious scum vibes.

[Gregness]

Ugh, that second to last line should read:

"The big point, to re-emphasize, is that I don't think low power = vanilla."

At what point is it okay to edit? I feel pretty dumb having to double-post for this.

[Bard The 5th LW]

There are officially no edit rules, but others might take it the wrong way.

[BahamutFlare]

Kerensky, I for sure can log on midnight EST. And you guys finished the lynch on IC 2 hours before I got to a computer. And now that it's evening and I have nowhere to go, I can post. Also, you were the weirdest acting on D1. Even you admitted you went to far. Usually I can see that as a classic cover up for scum. I'm always joking so you never know when I'm serious. I role claim mafia as a joke D1 but I'm not actually mafia. I just joke around. Then you claimed and there was no way I was going to lynch our vig. Not worth the risk. I immediately unvoted too.

My thoughts on yesterday was this also. IC role claimed as Bubblegum Half human half gum. I don't think the race/make-up of the person was given. I'm pretty sure LN says Princess Bubblegum, Mayor. Something simple. I'm surprised that didn't catch anyone else's eyes.

As of right now, I don't remember being told I was guarded which is odd. Greed seemed a bit of a complex role. Not sure if it's too much or what. No one even asked him to role-claim. I'm semi-suspicious of him. But LN did say. I just hope that it isn't a joint effort and there are secret votes or something like that like Hatland Mafia had. But I don't think it's enough to warrant a vote yet.

Kerensky, Gregness didn't say Vanilla. He didn't reveal what he can do. I just know Tree Trunks is the most kindest and annoying elephant ever. At least I don't think so. And Gregness even suspects scum vibes too. But like he said, you're pretty much confirmed. You're just shady like the night post said. :P

[Revising Ocelot]

Originally Posted by BahamutFlare

As of right now, I don't remember being told I was guarded which is odd.

Eh? Nobody said they were guarding you.

[BahamutFlare]

Originally Posted by Revolving Ocelot

Eh? Nobody said they were guarding you.

In other games. I don't think anyone I guarded was told that they were being guarded by me when I was Storm. I didn't mean this game.

[Nikose Tyris]

...One second while I flip a coin.

...Yep. VOTE: BAHAMUTFLARE