Batman Mafia

[Nikose Tyris]

Your role still fits with the storyline... whiiiiich to means we can extrapolate other roles in the game!

also: UNVOTE: Whoever I had voted for Because joke votes.

*gets to work on role list*

[Ravashak]

Hawk, not necessarily unkillable. In a previous game hosted by Moogle, I was part of the mafia, and the mafia could choose who to send to perform the kill. There were chars whose "power" was to be unkillable by a certain mafiate.

[The Artist Formerly Known as Hawk]

Originally Posted by Ravashak

Hawk, not necessarily unkillable. In a previous game hosted by Moogle, I was part of the mafia, and the mafia could choose who to send to perform the kill. There were chars whose "power" was to be unkillable by a certain mafiate.

Yeah I know, there's, 2 ways it works, either only 1 person has the kill until they die, then a second takes over, or they decide who performs the kill each night. Either way, telling everyone you're unkillable at all is a stupid thing to do because now they won't bother wasting a kill on him at all, or at least not with that person.

[Nikose Tyris]

@IHMN: Don't really care! This is how I always do my thing. Call me out on it if you want to, but it's how I typically play after silliness- and we have something of a reasonable lead here. Although feel free to lynch Aldurin- if it confirms him as Hush and his claims, it would mean my other theories about the game being based on this specific arc are very likely.

As for Roles likely to appear, and what might make sense as their role. All are random guesses at this point, but I'm fairly certain these roles are in game.

Joker - [...Not a clue. Probably mason'd with Harley]
Harley Quinn - [...Maybe bodyguard? Probably mason'd with Jokes.]
Two-Face - [...Kill role?]
Poison Ivy - [Investigator?]
Scarecrow - [Investigator?]
Killer Croc - [Kill role?]
Clay Face - [...no clue.]
Catwoman - [...Town Traitor?]
E. Nigma/Riddler - [Investigator?]
Mister Freeze is outside of the list of 'characters in this arc', but we already know he's in the game.

Any claim outside those role names would be suspect at best; anyone who claims these roles would likely get counterclaimed by the actual holder if they are bluffing.

[Ravashak]

True, but now he's put it in the open, I felt it wouldn't be bad to put it in perspective, considering the mafia should already know if the method I mentioned is to be used this game or not.

[Nique]

Vote: I believe the Detective is posing as a misbegotten fowl. Inbred Chocobo

[Nikose Tyris]

I'm pretty sure not including Freeze in a Batman themed game, regardless of plot or story, would be considered blasphemy.

[The Artist Formerly Known as Hawk]

That, and there are 19 of us. That's a lot of characters, regardless of arcs.

[Bard The 5th LW]

I'm not thinking we should really limit what we see to the arcs there associated with.

Anyways, FOS: Nikose because he's acting scummy and making a lot of leaps but really thats his default state of being so Im not sure if its worth bolding.

[The Artist Formerly Known as Hawk]

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

I'm not thinking we should really limit what we see to the arcs there associated with.

Anyways, FOS: Nikose because he's acting scummy and making a lot of leaps but really thats his default state of being so Im not sure if its worth bolding.

Yeah for now nothing is certain at all and I'm taking Nikoses ideas with the slimmest possible pinch of salt myself. But at least we ahve disscussion now and a few things to go on, so I want to hear from other people now on their thoughts on stuff and see where that leads us. And then after night 1 we'll have more info. Day 1 is usually a bust anyway but who knows, maybe we'll get lucky?