Batman Mafia - Page 9

Nikose Tyris · 01-03-2012, 06:49 PM

In fairness, I was his staunchest and only supporter. I can see him getting angry about that.

Gregness · 01-03-2012, 06:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aldurin

Fuck you too, Nikose.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fenris

This wasn't really necessary.

Yeah, I wasn't really on board with this before but this sort of outburst is super suspicious.

Vote: Aldurin

Geminex · 01-03-2012, 09:10 PM

Whoa whoa whoa. What are we even doing here. Cause it looks to me like we're lyching a dude based on a perfectly plausible roleclaim. Earl claimed miller. He might be miller. He might be scum too, sure. I'm not saying he's definitely town. But how the hell does claiming miller make him suspicious? It COULD BE a clever ruse by scum. Yes. But it's just as likely, if not more so, that it's genuine. It could easily be either. And in that light, I find it really hard to understand why it makes for proper voting justification. Hell, you had Hawk with a fakeclaim that almost seemed serious, you have IHMN mandating a frankly horrible tactic. Both of those I could have gotten behind, because fakeclaims confuse people and mandating lyches on everyone who claims miller is not only silly, it also results in town wasting at least one lynch. Both of those are scumtells, albeit minor (giving IHMN the benefit of the doubt here, but reluctantly). So why're the votes piling on earl?

Nikose Tyris · 01-03-2012, 09:13 PM

Well, he could have hit the random button the batman wiki and taken the first Villain he hadn't heard of, I think is what Hawk's point is.

I actually semi-trust Aldurin's claim, but it's mafia, and I am probably stupid for trusting people.

Also, if his lynch turns out to be Hush, I can feel a bit more confident in my assertions, and can start figuring out what likely power roles are here.

Nikose Tyris · 01-03-2012, 09:13 PM

However, UNVOTE: ALDURIN

Because you're right, Gem. I believe he's telling the truth here, and sacrifice for theory isn't the brightest thing I could do here.

Nikose Tyris · 01-03-2012, 09:16 PM

[OTOH if he turns up mafia I'm going to point my sniffer at you, Gems. <3]

Gregness · 01-03-2012, 09:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Geminex

Whoa whoa whoa. What are we even doing here. Cause it looks to me like we're lyching a dude based on a perfectly plausible roleclaim. Earl claimed miller. He might be miller. He might be scum too, sure. I'm not saying he's definitely town. But how the hell does claiming miller make him suspicious? It COULD BE a clever ruse by scum. Yes. But it's just as likely, if not more so, that it's genuine. It could easily be either. And in that light, I find it really hard to understand why it makes for proper voting justification. Hell, you had Hawk with a fakeclaim that almost seemed serious, you have IHMN mandating a frankly horrible tactic. Both of those I could have gotten behind, because fakeclaims confuse people and mandating lyches on everyone who claims miller is not only silly, it also results in town wasting at least one lynch. Both of those are scumtells, albeit minor (giving IHMN the benefit of the doubt here, but reluctantly). So why're the votes piling on earl?

The miller claim I don't mind. The emotional outburst from a tiny bit of pressure? That's much more telling.

Aldurin · 01-03-2012, 09:39 PM

I get slightly dramatic when it starts to slow down, mixed with sarcasm that can make my non-serious comments really hard to read. Sorry about that.

If you go ahead with this lynch, you'll come to day 2 with a nominal amount of info to work with and more people dead. If you really want me lynched that bad, at least have the courtesy to look at other people and try to find possible leads.

Nique · 01-03-2012, 09:42 PM

It seems like a bad idea to lynch a roleclaim in normal mafia unless there's a really compelling reason (like if you catch them in a lie or something) but then I remembered that we're all playing an unknown villain with an unknown ability and could basically make up whatever we wanted.

Also sometimes people take Mafia too seriously.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aldurin

I get slightly dramatic when it starts to slow down, mixed with sarcasm that can make my non-serious comments really hard to read. Sorry about that.

For what it's worth, I figured you were funnin'. Maybe we should roleplay our outbursts so we all know it's an in-game thing?

BahamutFlare · 01-03-2012, 10:20 PM

The weirdest thing for me is Aldurin started getting nervous way too early. 3 votes on him then a bit of a breakdown. In order to lynch, he needed a LOT more. And just a couple serious votes sent him over the edge? He's acting more like he's been caught rather then trying to defend himself. And then the f you to Nikose.

Fenris has been fairly low content. Not trying to pry info out of anyone. Not giving info. He's kinda the bad kind of quiet IMO.

Vote: P-Sleazy

Because he's complaining about not being dead.

Unvote: P-Sleazy
Vote: Aldurin
I just feel like you're trying to justify flipping out. But you acted like you were caught.

01-03-2012, 09:10 PM	#83
Geminex SOM3WH3R3 Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 4,606	Whoa whoa whoa. What are we even doing here. Cause it looks to me like we're lyching a dude based on a perfectly plausible roleclaim. Earl claimed miller. He might be miller. He might be scum too, sure. I'm not saying he's definitely town. But how the hell does claiming miller make him suspicious? It COULD BE a clever ruse by scum. Yes. But it's just as likely, if not more so, that it's genuine. It could easily be either. And in that light, I find it really hard to understand why it makes for proper voting justification. Hell, you had Hawk with a fakeclaim that almost seemed serious, you have IHMN mandating a frankly horrible tactic. Both of those I could have gotten behind, because fakeclaims confuse people and mandating lyches on everyone who claims miller is not only silly, it also results in town wasting at least one lynch. Both of those are scumtells, albeit minor (giving IHMN the benefit of the doubt here, but reluctantly). So why're the votes piling on earl?

01-03-2012, 09:39 PM	#88
Aldurin Lakitu Join Date: Feb 2010 Posts: 4,648	I get slightly dramatic when it starts to slow down, mixed with sarcasm that can make my non-serious comments really hard to read. Sorry about that. If you go ahead with this lynch, you'll come to day 2 with a nominal amount of info to work with and more people dead. If you really want me lynched that bad, at least have the courtesy to look at other people and try to find possible leads.

01-03-2012, 10:20 PM	#90
BahamutFlare Troopa Join Date: Oct 2011 Location: PA Posts: 34	The weirdest thing for me is Aldurin started getting nervous way too early. 3 votes on him then a bit of a breakdown. In order to lynch, he needed a LOT more. And just a couple serious votes sent him over the edge? He's acting more like he's been caught rather then trying to defend himself. And then the f you to Nikose. Fenris has been fairly low content. Not trying to pry info out of anyone. Not giving info. He's kinda the bad kind of quiet IMO. Vote: P-Sleazy Because he's complaining about not being dead. Unvote: P-Sleazy Vote: Aldurin I just feel like you're trying to justify flipping out. But you acted like you were caught.