Mafia Time!

[Aldurin]

I agree with Kerensky.

[Lawful Neutral]

Unvote: Gregness
Vote: Moogle

Gonna have to go with the majority this time.

[Moogle0119]

Is everyone voting for me just because "hey, it's not me"? I just want everyone's reasons clarified before the lynch goes through.

[Mr.Bookworm]

Originally Posted by Moogle0119

Is everyone voting for me just because "hey, it's not me"? I just want everyone's reasons clarified before the lynch goes through.

I would say your role comes across as extremely suspicious, as it's very, very hard to verify. Going to hold off on voting for you right now, though.

I personally would guess that there is only one mafiate left. We had 12 people at the start of the game IIRC, and 1:4 is the usual Mafia:Town ratio.

There might be a cult (Lumpy Space Princess, probably), in which case they have a pretty severe advantage right now. I would step back and take a look at all of the "confirmed" roleclaims and see if we notice anything suspicious.

I'd say that if we kill another mafiate and the game is still going, we can be pretty assured that there is a cult.

[greed]

Originally Posted by Lawful Neutral

I am curious to know what Greed's third power is. Choose Goose has been seen with the Glasses and the Armor of Zelderon in-show, but beyond that, there aren't any artifacts tied to him, hmmm...

Sadly my third power is largely useless, it was the ability to let someone mason with Princess Bubblegum. However seeing as you were the first town role revealed it's effectiveness went down the drain. The artifact in question was the holopendant.

[Bard The 5th LW]

Votecount

Moogle: 3 (Kerensky, Aldurin, Lawful Neutral)
Gregness: 1 (Moogle)
Ryanderman: 1 (Gregness)

With 9 players left it takes 5 to lynch. Day will probably end thursday or so if a majority is not reached.

Mightve missed a vote, not sure.

[rpgdemon]

Originally Posted by Aldurin

*sigh*

Hey rpg, should we just let them see our communications so that they know for sure that we are masoned with gem and thus town? Like just link to it?

And now that I think about it.

Unvote: Bookworm

Vote: Moogle

He pushing really hard for lynches, and his roleclaim is convenient in the way that it is extremely difficult to verify. And his recent arguments feel more antagonistic than helpful toward town.

I PMed Bard to see if it's kosher to do so, but I accidentally said Kerensky instead of Geminex, so then he addressed that in his PM back, and nothing about the legitimateness of the idea.

[Gregness]

First thing: Bard, you did miss a vote

Originally Posted by Gregness

*snip*
Vote: Ryanderman

FoS: Moogle0119
for pushing hard for my lynch despite the dearth of evidence. Honestly, this would go for Kerensky and LN too except that they're basically confirmed at this point whereas we've only got Moogle's word that he's a watcher.

FoS: Mr. Bookworm
For being extremely inactive.

Now, for content!

Originally Posted by Kerensky287

Yeah, sorry about the loose-cannon lynch on Nikose.

I feel like I should have mentioned WHY I was suspicious of him - his method of flipping a coin to decide who to lynch is scummy as fuck, for example - but... eh. I didn't want to give him any warning, and it was sort of a spur-of-the-moment thing.

*snip*

I actually completely agree with you that the coinflip thing was scummy as hell. Nikose had just built up enough town-cred with me day 1 that I just chalked it up to him being nutty and made a note to recheck it if something didn't add up later.

Moogle, I originally had suspicions of you, but they were less than my suspicions of Book and Ryander. That was before you spent the last few pages doing this:

Originally Posted by Moogle0119

Gonna keep that record going Kerensky, really?

Originally Posted by Moogle0119

Kerensky you're seriously misguided this game. If this lynch goes through you should SERIOUSLY consider targeting Aldurin or rpgdemon tonight with one of your kills since you won't listen to logic anymore. Maybe you'll listen to me once I turn up town though? Or maybe not.

This all seems very personal-attackey and raises my suspicions of you to the point where I'm not sure if it's you or Ryander.

I'm still keeping my vote on Ryanderman for now so we can keep discussing.

[Kerensky287]

Bard, don't you mean 4 for Moogle? Lawful has 2 votes.

[Moogle0119]

Those weren't personal attacks on Kerensky (at least not intended to be). I'm trying to steer town away from making a poor lynch decision. Nobody has yet bothered to voice why they suspect me other than "Suspicious role claim" or "Personal attacks". I only roleclaimed yesterday BECAUSE I was asked to and I have been nothing but honest about my choices so far and my findings. People have tried twisting my watching Bookie into me claiming his innocent, which I have denied from the start. Only that Bookie did not perform a kill at night. Then others still wanted to target him for a lynch originally and my question was why? Even if he was the 2nd mafiate, that still leaves another mafiate in the list we came up with originally either way.

Edit: Here. If I'm scum (which I'm not) then yes that would basically prove Bookie is scum as well. If I'm NOT scum, it does not prove Bookie is innocent at all and then you will have killed a town resource for gathering information. If we lynch Aldurin or rpgdemon and either of them turns up as scum, we can lynch the other. If either of them turns up as town then it entirely proves the other's innocence. Plus if I survive another night I am able to give town more information on whoever I end up watching. Lynching me instead does nothing (doesn't prove Aldurin, rpg, or Bookie are anything) since I will turn up town and you will just be down one minor town power that may or may not prove useful.