Homestuck Mafia Thread

rpgdemon · 07-27-2011, 02:20 PM

Not from someone who's acting suspiciously.

I'm a new player as well, but I didn't see you jumping in on my account when I followed Thadius's lead of not voting, in the beginning of the game.

Not that I have any proof for you guys, but I'm a townie. And I'm being undefended by you. You can't have a defense for not defending all the new players of knowing that Bard and Thadius are townies, since it's impossible to know that, unless you're scum. Your preferences, however, could be logically made, if you had knowledge that Bard and Thad are scum, if you're scum.

The only reason that you'd pick certain new players to defend, and ignore others, would be if you had scummy knowledge. Even if I weren't a townie, your actions would still be defensible, because you could be picking people who you would know are innocent to defend, they know they're innocent, and then you look good for defending them.

P-Sleazy · 07-27-2011, 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

Not from someone who's acting suspiciously.

I'm a new player as well, but I didn't see you jumping in on my account when I followed Thadius's lead of not voting, in the beginning of the game.

Not that I have any proof for you guys, but I'm a townie. And I'm being undefended by you. You can't have a defense for not defending all the new players of knowing that Bard and Thadius are townies, since it's impossible to know that, unless you're scum. Your preferences, however, could be logically made, if you had knowledge that Bard and Thad are scum, if you're scum.

The only reason that you'd pick certain new players to defend, and ignore others, would be if you had scummy knowledge. Even if I weren't a townie, your actions would still be defensible, because you could be picking people who you would know are innocent to defend, they know they're innocent, and then you look good for defending them.

Or it could be that I didn't attack anyone for voting no lynch. But rather made the comment that voting no lynch is a very bad move to inform you guys of that and moved on with the game, taking everyone's no lynch as if it hadn't happened. Considering most everyone moved away, there was no reason to defend you about that.

What am I supposed to be defending you from?

So you're saying that both Bard and Thadius are scum because I'm defending them? Both town and hope they'll rally beside me in my call to vote sifright? I think not. I've given them both one post, the same post infact, to point out flaws in other peoples votes on them, and why I disagree with thier votes.

I then made the comment that uncle sleazy will give them some kind of defense so they're not just like "well, crap, what do I do now?"

07-27-2011, 02:20 PM	#1
rpgdemon Not a Taco Join Date: May 2005 Posts: 3,313	Not from someone who's acting suspiciously. I'm a new player as well, but I didn't see you jumping in on my account when I followed Thadius's lead of not voting, in the beginning of the game. Not that I have any proof for you guys, but I'm a townie. And I'm being undefended by you. You can't have a defense for not defending all the new players of knowing that Bard and Thadius are townies, since it's impossible to know that, unless you're scum. Your preferences, however, could be logically made, if you had knowledge that Bard and Thad are scum, if you're scum. The only reason that you'd pick certain new players to defend, and ignore others, would be if you had scummy knowledge. Even if I weren't a townie, your actions would still be defensible, because you could be picking people who you would know are innocent to defend, they know they're innocent, and then you look good for defending them. __________________ I did a lot of posting on here as a teenager, and I was pretty awful. Even after I learned, grew up, and came to be on the right side of a lot of important issues, I was still angry, abrasive, and generally increased the amount of hate in the world, in pretty unacceptable ways. On the off chance that someone is taking a trip down memory lane looking through those old threads, I wanted to devote my signature to say directly to you, I'm sorry. Thank you for letting me be better, NPF.