It shattered you illusion of the character who in the beginning went into what he knew was a trap solely because the sign said "Evil Pie"?
I don't get why you guys don't understand BM's secret passion for baked goods. I like his argument. He had me at the line "But I figure there's more kinds of cake than fire, so the odds are actually in my favor".
I would invent new kinds of cake just to improve those odds.